Here is a presentation given by James Howard Kunstler titled “The Tragedy of Suburbia.” Kunstler is the author of The Geography of Nowhere, a history of suburbia and urban development in the U.S. Kunstler is a proponent of New Urbanism, which strives to reform many aspects of real estate development and urban planning, from urban retrofits to suburban infill. New urbanist neighborhoods are designed to contain a diverse range of housing and jobs, and to be walkable. Worth a look, with some of my comments below.
* Possibly NSFW: Kunstler takes a provocative stance in this presentation, and occasionally uses some adult language.
Kustler spoke of how defining space is critical to creating a place of character and quality. With regard to landscaping, this means avoiding the temptation to install a “Nature Band-Aid”- a random or ill-planned planting intended to compensate for an otherwise vacant or dismal area. While there may not be much we can do about the location or architecture of our homes, we can use landscaping to define space and create character and quality for our homes.
The use of space is one of my first considerations when designing a project. This goes beyond whether there is enough room for a particular plant to grow, mature and thrive, but whether the planting compliments the surrounding environment and/or serves a purpose, be it aesthetic or utilitarian.
Perhaps the biggest problem I encounter when evaluating an existing landscape is poor planning. For instance, too often I see trees planted within several feet of a foundation… this might seem fine when the plant is six feet tall, but what happens when they grow to thirty feet tall and are eating the second story gutter and cracking the foundation? My own home features a white pine planted within six feet of the foundation– it was a Christmas tree 30 years ago and probably looked charming when it was planted. I’m sure the original homeowners thought (correctly) that the corner of the house needed “something,” and they did manage to save a cute little tree from the mulch shredder. Today, that white pine is easily over sixty feet tall, drips sap all over the driveway and sends limbs crashing down on the garage roof after nearly every storm. Not to mention the deluge of pine needles in the Fall. White pines are excellent trees and certainly have a place in landscape design, but the tree in question is destined to become mulch someday because of poor planning. The tree (and the property) would have been better served had it been located in a space where it had room to grow.
Good landscape planning should, in my view, mature gracefully. The planting should improve with age and help define the space in which we live.









